Friday, November 20, 2026

What is Calvinism? And what do Calvinists believe?

Calvin may be the post-Biblical theologian I have studied more than any other. Today I had lots of fun looking at my dusty undergraduate notes on The Institutes. I don't know if I thought paper was in short supply, but I seem to have written very neatly all over the A4. If you are attending a PCC or other meeting in your church or church zpne, please count me in.

Calvin was not keen on the idea that there should be "Calvinists".

Calvin was a member of a family of Reformed Churches. Luther, Zwingli, Calvin were perhaps the big three. 

England was influenced by Luther, of course, but the English Reformation was essentially Calvinist.

(There was also a Radical Reformation. And a Counter Reformation) 

There is some debate about to what extent Calvin was a Calvinist. Once can of course find aspects of the later Reformed Scholastics which differed from Calvin, and continuity.  R. T. Kendal wrote Calvin and English Calvinism to 1649 (Studies in Christian History and Thought) (1979, OUP). 

See the review here by Tony Lane. Trueman and Clark also published a volume of essays on Protestant Scholasticism: Essays in Reassessment, which I seem to recall paid some attention to issues of development. 

Calvin is associated with the doctrine of predestination. Alexandre Schweizer (1844) and Ferdinand Christian (1847) influenced many to see Predestination, which is of course taught by Paul and St Augustine of Hippo, and others, as the single controlling idea for Calvin. Predestination was not even a separate point of doctrine in the 1536 edition of The Institutes and was only mentioned twice. In the 1559 edition, the doctrine was largely confined to the four chapters (III, xxiff) specifically devoted to it. The expansion is largely made up of additional Scriptural citations and responses to criticisms so it cannot be said that the idea was taking over Calvin's mind. 

Much ink has been spilled on what, if anything, should be thought the heart of Calvin's "system". The glory of God is a key theme. The sovereignty of God is important. Union with Christ is central. Calvin might be called more of a biblical than systematic theologian, but his thought is coherent and integrated. 

The Trinity has also been claimed as pervasive in Calvin's thought. It is an antidote to idolatry (I, xiif). And Calvin's whole view of salvation is thoroughly Trinitarian. Salvation is decreed and elected by the Father, revealed, achieved and established by the Son, and applied and made effectual to the believer by the Spirit. God is benevolent, he promises Christ, and this is sealed and revealed by the Holy Spirit. Calvin's doctrine of the Supper is also Trinitarian.

Calvin is not really an overly rationalistic theologian. He wants to focus on God as he reveals himself, not speculate about his essence. He will say that the secret things belong to God and appeal to mystery. Dt 29:29. When Calvin asks why God created some to be damned, he will say you reason, I marvel, and claim that some matters are simply unrevealed. Calvin is a theologian of revelation, a biblical theologian. He is aiming to provide a dogmatic introduction to the reading of Scripture.   

Calvin was a great student of the Patristics, as Prof Anthony Lane has shown. John Calvin, student of the church fathers (Baker, 1999)

One can debate what Calvin's unique contribution was. Not the so-called extra-Calvinisticum. One small point is perhaps his belief (following Bucer) that Doctor was a special office in the church.

See this review of Brannon Ellis. Calvin, Classical Trinitarianism, and the Aseity of the Son. OUP, 2012. "Ellis proposes that we best understand John Calvin’s infamous assertion of the Son’s aseity as a self-conscious attempt at consistently employing this pro-Nicene grammar." 

Too often Calvin and Calvinism are misunderstood and caricatured. G. K. Chesterton, for example, tends to use the term as one of abuse. 

No comments: