How
to write a book review for publication in a Christian academic theology journal
such
as Church Society's The Global Anglican
There are two great commandments of
book reviewing.
The first is to love your readers,
those for whom the review is intended. It is to help
and serve them. Inform and entertain. Be accurate and engaging. Summarise.
Include a representative or telling quote. Give a flavour. Who might benefit
from this book? How might it be used? How technical / accessible is it? Give us
your judgement. Engage with the thesis. Add to what we could get from the
publisher’s website or from the look inside feature on Amazon. Did you agree
with it and like it? Is it well written? Is there other stuff in the field that
we should also read? How does this work fit in to the current state of studies
(e.g. it builds on Smith and Jones, while refuting Bloggs and Davies)? Does it
advance scholarship? What is its unique contribution?
The second commandment is like it.
Love the author, who laboured to write the book you are reviewing.
Do to him or her what you would have them do unto you. Be fair to him or her.
Be kind. Imagine the writer reading your review. Remember that those who can
write books, and those who can’t review books. By all means, if you
like, tell us this is not the book you would have written. Fine. But that’s not
really what we’re asking. Try to assess the book on its own terms. Why was it
written? What is the author aiming to do? Does he or she succeed in her aims?
You may also tell us other things the author might have said, but there is
always more one could say, so whilst there can be glaring omissions, you might
like to show us why this gap matters.
Also, you can love the reviews editor
by trying to be timely and helpful. Often reviews
need no editing. But it is helpful if you don’t necessarily want to die in a
ditch over every word and comma. (After the review is accepted, and any edits
agreed, there may be an additional copy editing phase when we would tidy up any
punctuation errors etc. We do not revert to reviewers over these). We also
cannot promise when we will publish your review. And just because we asked you
to write a review, we are not promising to publish it if there is some pressing
reason not to and we don’t think we can reasonably make it usable.
Some other suggestions and pleas, more
or less at random:
Do not tell us that every Christian should
read this book. Unless you are reviewing the Bible! And even then different
translations and versions are available.
If the book is standout brilliant, do say so.
Don’t say that of every book you read. Many books are fine, good and helpful.
It is useful to know if you think the book is stella, okay or weak.
Write a book review which shows the fruit of
the Spirit.
Write about the book, not just about yourself
and the times you have met the author.
If there is something interesting or relevant
about the author, tell us that. You may want to point out what fits the author
to write the book if that is not already well-known. Is he particularly
qualified to address this subject? Is his previous work relevant? Is he writing
in a field where he is an Oxbridge Professor or is this an Old Testament
specialist trying his hand at pastoral theology?
Please read the whole book, every word,
carefully. You may read a third of the book and be pretty sure what you want to
say about it, but try to remain open. There may be some terrible heresy or
error on the final page!
Mark the book and make notes from the
beginning of your reading. Maybe when you have finished the book, sleep on it
before you write your review. When you finish your review, maybe sleep on it
before you send it in.
Use the publisher’s template. Try to conform
to the Style Guide as far as you know it, but no one expects you to spend hours
memorising the SBL handbook or the Chicago Manual. Please just do
what you can carefully to the best of your lights. Those serious about writing
may also like to read things on style. There is some fun stuff out there. For
example, you might enjoy Simon Heffer’s series Scarcely, Simply and Strictly
English (Penguin). Other useful reference tools include New Hart’s
Rules: The Handbook of Style for Writers and Editors, The New Oxford
Dictionary for Writers and Editors and Oxford A-Z of Grammar &
Punctuation (OUP).
We are looking for a reasonably formal
academic style. Try to be as clear as you can. There’s no need to show off your
learning.
If you are new to reviewing, you might like to
try reading your review out loud. Or ask a friend to read it for you.
Write at a level suitable to the journal. If
the journal is for New Testament specialists, you can of course assume
specialist knowledge. But if your journal seeks to appeal to the bookish Vicar
or even the keen lay person, as well as the experts in various sub-disciples,
it is probably okay to assume undergraduate theology knowledge but not that all
your readers will have a PhD in the topic under consideration. Perhaps err on
the side of simplicity and clarity rather than jargon.
If you quote, please give the page
number.
Make the review as long as it needs to be.
Sometimes you can’t say everything. Sometimes longer and shorter versions of a
review might be useful. Could you publish a fuller version online with the
permission of the journal? Brevity is probably the soul of wit. The journal may
be open to a brief book note or to a longer review essay.
If this book is a re-write or second edition
or re-publication or uses material previously published elsewhere etc. that may
be information your public wants. You may wish to tell us if this book is part
of a series or larger project. Is it volume 2 of 4?
If the journal has also reviewed some other
work you mention please cite it e.g. in the form: TGA 2026 140/3 p282-3.
The academic review is not quite the same as a
review in a magazine or newspaper, but you are still allowed to be engaging and
interesting. How might you begin and end the review? Could your review be
called predictable and formulaic? Can you give your review a hook or angle,
rather than simply plodding through the chapters?
You may well feel moved to complain about the
prices of academic books, but if we always did that our reviews would be rather
samey.
Don’t moan about the book being American if it
was written by an American for Americans, and you are writing for an American
journal. If the journal has Global Anglican in the title, you might say how
global Anglicans might find the book.
Check with the journal before publishing your
review online.
We also have one page of A4 which sets out our
“aspirations” for reviews, which you might find helpful.
Thank you!
I would love to hear your thoughts.