Friday, November 20, 2026

Get Organised!

You would do really well to get organised. And to stay organised. This is especially important if there is no administrator and three churches to lead.

Some parishes will be more organised than others. And it is worth investing in this. For example, does your Electoral Roll Officer ask for phone numbers and emails and invite people to fill in a GDPR declaration and join the church WhatsApp group? Or is it actually a bit of a drama even if you want to phone some of the regulars.  

I would suggest having the following equipment with you:

 

A large diary. I like paper. I find it faster than using a phone. Ideally, have an extensive Christian calendar in your diary. You may want the lectionary. Please write clearly and in full. I have lost count of the number of times that I have squiggled an abbreviation in a corner and been left wondering what on earth 2pm GH @ CHH was meant to mean. You can also use your diary to send messages to yourself in the future. Of course this is only effective if you look at it! So tasks can be written in the diary “Buy Christmas tracts” not just where you have to go and when.

 

If people are ever going to look over your shoulder in the diary and you want some space for yourself or your family you can schedule an appointment. No, I’m sorry, I can’t do Wednesday morning. 9am – 12pm SO. Something On. That time is reserved for preparing the sermon, or whatever.

 

If you are going to visit a parishioner for the first time, it is helpful to write their address and phone number in the diary and the purpose of the visit, if you might forget it. Sarah Jones – 2nd visit re baptism at Warbleton. Did you ask for directions? The postcode may not lead you there. What Three Words can be useful.

 

And you need a notebook. All notes in the notebook. No scraps of paper to be lost. Write in tasks. Cross out when completed. Review. You are now pretty organised.

 

I also really recommend working on the principles of Dave Allen, Getting Things Done: The Art of Stress-free Productivity (Piatkus, 2015)[1]. Allen argues you need good “buckets” for capturing your incoming stuff. Marking an email as unread my not be enough. You need to:

 

DO – just get it done esp. if it takes less than 2 mins (deferring takes some time so…)

DEFER – have a way to remind yourself to do it at later more suitable time. Make a note in your diary or notebook

DELEGATE – could someone else do it?

DON’T! – some things you might deliberately leave undone

 

Allen thinks that if you are not trying to remember to call Sarah and to get the cake out of the oven and email the flower arrangers, you will be calmer, happier and more creative. Capture those tasks!

 

He also thinks it is good to record all your major projects e.g. REDEVELOP WEBSITE. The key is the identify specific NEXT ACTIONS – e.g. look at suggestions from the various leaders after they have had a week to send it in. Some actions may be time or place conditional. Are there things you want to do or remember next time you are in the study or in each of your churches? You could organise your next actions in this way.

 

It is also helpful to record what you are WAITING FOR since if David fails to reply, in a few days you’ll want to check if he actually got that email.

 

I suggest always taking a Bible with you. I believe John Stott used to get it out of his brief case before going in to a pastoral visit. He obviously came above all not with his diary for a business meeting but with his Bible as a minister of the Gospel.

You may also want another book and a biro. Should you find yourself waiting at the Crem you could read and mark a few pages.  

I still find a business card useful.

 You could always have a gospel, a tract and an invite to church or to Christianity Explored in your bag. 

I always carry all the church keys with me. My training incumbent in a large town centre church told me never to bring my keys to church. I would only find myself being the verger. But I have found it necessary.

 

I also always carry drawing pins. 50% of parish ministry is taking down the old posters and putting up new ones so be prepared.

Your filing system isn't so much for filing as for retrieval. Think about it! When will you need this thing again? Will you know where to look? GTD suggested a file for every day of the year, or something, tickets for that concert filed in the correct day. That seems to me to be going a bit far, but maybe you might have a "Forthcoming" file. 

You may be able to "search" rather than "sort", but will your computer find that file? Will you used the word you search for?

Oh, and just to be honest for a moment: if you could see my desk right now, you would know there is an element of wishful thinking do as I say not as I do here! 


[1] This can be used with old school paper or digital tools. https://store.gettingthingsdone.com/product-category/setup-guides/?gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=20321990121&gbraid=0AAAAAD22tVH4XjOjClrytqv9nNi4dywmE&gclid=Cj0KCQiA_P_XBhDvARIsALHjSUW6DKUfcMLygcvzaKk2iLLaoKmcPPYBSV0z6QS51WYzRMn2Lp6qZzUaAhKVEALw_wcB

What is Calvinism? And what do Calvinists believe?

Calvin may be the post-Biblical theologian I have studied more than any other. Today I had lots of fun looking at my dusty undergraduate notes on The Institutes. I don't know if I thought paper was in short supply, but I seem to have written very neatly all over the A4. If you are attending a PCC or other meeting in your church or church zpne, please count me in.

Calvin was not keen on the idea that there should be "Calvinists".

Calvin was a member of a family of Reformed Churches. Luther, Zwingli, Calvin were perhaps the big three. 

England was influenced by Luther, of course, but the English Reformation was essentially Calvinist.

(There was also a Radical Reformation. And a Counter Reformation) 

There is some debate about to what extent Calvin was a Calvinist. Once can of course find aspects of the later Reformed Scholastics which differed from Calvin, and continuity.  R. T. Kendal wrote Calvin and English Calvinism to 1649 (Studies in Christian History and Thought) (1979, OUP). 

See the review here by Tony Lane. Trueman and Clark also published a volume of essays on Protestant Scholasticism: Essays in Reassessment, which I seem to recall paid some attention to issues of development. 

Calvin is associated with the doctrine of predestination. Alexandre Schweizer (1844) and Ferdinand Christian (1847) influenced many to see Predestination, which is of course taught by Paul and St Augustine of Hippo, and others, as the single controlling idea for Calvin. Predestination was not even a separate point of doctrine in the 1536 edition of The Institutes and was only mentioned twice. In the 1559 edition, the doctrine was largely confined to the four chapters (III, xxiff) specifically devoted to it. The expansion is largely made up of additional Scriptural citations and responses to criticisms so it cannot be said that the idea was taking over Calvin's mind. 

Much ink has been spilled on what, if anything, should be thought the heart of Calvin's "system". The glory of God is a key theme. The sovereignty of God is important. Union with Christ is central. Calvin might be called more of a biblical than systematic theologian, but his thought is coherent and integrated. 

The Trinity has also been claimed as pervasive in Calvin's thought. It is an antidote to idolatry (I, xiif). And Calvin's whole view of salvation is thoroughly Trinitarian. Salvation is decreed and elected by the Father, revealed, achieved and established by the Son, and applied and made effectual to the believer by the Spirit. God is benevolent, he promises Christ, and this is sealed and revealed by the Holy Spirit. Calvin's doctrine of the Supper is also Trinitarian.

Calvin is not really an overly rationalistic theologian. He wants to focus on God as he reveals himself, not speculate about his essence. He will say that the secret things belong to God and appeal to mystery. Dt 29:29. When Calvin asks why God created some to be damned, he will say you reason, I marvel, and claim that some matters are simply unrevealed. Calvin is a theologian of revelation, a biblical theologian. He is aiming to provide a dogmatic introduction to the reading of Scripture.   

Calvin was a great student of the Patristics, as Prof Anthony Lane has shown. John Calvin, student of the church fathers (Baker, 1999)

One can debate what Calvin's unique contribution was. Not the so-called extra-Calvinisticum. One small point is perhaps his belief (following Bucer) that Doctor was a special office in the church.

See this review of Brannon Ellis. Calvin, Classical Trinitarianism, and the Aseity of the Son. OUP, 2012. "Ellis proposes that we best understand John Calvin’s infamous assertion of the Son’s aseity as a self-conscious attempt at consistently employing this pro-Nicene grammar." 

Too often Calvin and Calvinism are misunderstood and caricatured. G. K. Chesterton, for example, tends to use the term as one of abuse. 

Can Almighty God do Anything?

God's omnipotence does not mean he can do anything. 

Who would want to be able to do anything?!

We only want to be able to do what we want to do.

God cannot lie. He cannot change. He cannot fail. Or sin. Or die. Or cease to be. Or forget his covenant. Or deny himself.

He cannot make a square triangle.

God cannot make a stone so heavy that he can't lift it. Though he can deal with those who ask silly questions. 

These things are no lack of power.

God can do all things compatible with his perfect nature. God's power will never run out or fail.  

God's omnipotence means than no one can thwart him. He always achieves his purposes. He has no rivals. 

God's power is not arbitrary. It is wise and kind and holy and...

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

How to write a book review

 

How to write a book review for publication in a Christian academic theology journal

such as Church Society's The Global Anglican

 

There are two great commandments of book reviewing.

 

The first is to love your readers, those for whom the review is intended. It is to help and serve them. Inform and entertain. Be accurate and engaging. Summarise. Include a representative or telling quote. Give a flavour. Who might benefit from this book? How might it be used? How technical / accessible is it? Give us your judgement. Engage with the thesis. Add to what we could get from the publisher’s website or from the look inside feature on Amazon. Did you agree with it and like it? Is it well written? Is there other stuff in the field that we should also read? How does this work fit in to the current state of studies (e.g. it builds on Smith and Jones, while refuting Bloggs and Davies)? Does it advance scholarship? What is its unique contribution?

 

The second commandment is like it. Love the author, who laboured to write the book you are reviewing. Do to him or her what you would have them do unto you. Be fair to him or her. Be kind. Imagine the writer reading your review. Remember that those who can write books, and those who can’t review books. By all means, if you like, tell us this is not the book you would have written. Fine. But that’s not really what we’re asking. Try to assess the book on its own terms. Why was it written? What is the author aiming to do? Does he or she succeed in her aims? You may also tell us other things the author might have said, but there is always more one could say, so whilst there can be glaring omissions, you might like to show us why this gap matters.

 

Also, you can love the reviews editor by trying to be timely and helpful. Often reviews need no editing. But it is helpful if you don’t necessarily want to die in a ditch over every word and comma. (After the review is accepted, and any edits agreed, there may be an additional copy editing phase when we would tidy up any punctuation errors etc. We do not revert to reviewers over these). We also cannot promise when we will publish your review. And just because we asked you to write a review, we are not promising to publish it if there is some pressing reason not to, and we don’t think we can reasonably make it usable.  

 

Some other suggestions and pleas, more or less at random:

 

Do not tell us that every Christian should read this book. Unless you are reviewing the Bible! And even then different translations and versions are available.

 

If the book is standout brilliant, do say so. Don’t say that of every book you read. Many books are fine, good and helpful. It is useful to know if you think the book is stella, okay or weak.

 

Write a book review which shows the fruit of the Spirit.

 

Write about the book, not just about yourself and the times you have met the author.

 

If there is something interesting or relevant about the author, tell us that. You may want to point out what fits the author to write the book if that is not already well-known. Is he particularly qualified to address this subject? Is her previous work relevant? Is he writing in a field where he is an Oxbridge Professor or is this an Old Testament specialist trying his hand at pastoral theology?

 

Please read the whole book, every word, carefully. You may read a third of the book and be pretty sure what you want to say about it, but try to remain open. There may be some terrible heresy or error on the final page!

 

Mark the book and make notes from the beginning of your reading. Maybe when you have finished the book, sleep on it before you write your review. When you finish your review, maybe sleep on it before you send it in.

 

Use the publisher’s template. Try to conform to the Style Guide as far as you know it, but no one expects you to spend hours memorising the SBL handbook or the Chicago Manual. Please just do what you can carefully to the best of your lights. Those serious about writing may also like to read things on style. There is some fun stuff out there. For example, you might enjoy Simon Heffer’s series Scarcely, Simply and Strictly English (Penguin). Other useful reference tools include New Hart’s Rules: The Handbook of Style for Writers and Editors, The New Oxford Dictionary for Writers and Editors and Oxford A-Z of Grammar & Punctuation (OUP). Perhaps the best ways to grow as a writer are to read, to write and to get feedback. Book reviewing can be a great way to begin writing. 

 

We are looking for a reasonably formal academic style. Try to be as clear as you can. There’s no need to show off your learning. Short sentences. Anglo-Saxon. Precise language, not big words because you think they sound better. 

 

If you are new to reviewing, you might like to try reading your review out loud. Or ask a friend to read it for you.

 

Write at a level suitable to the journal. If the journal is for New Testament specialists, you can of course assume specialist knowledge. But if your journal seeks to appeal to the bookish Vicar or even the keen lay person, as well as the experts in various sub-disciples, it is probably okay to assume undergraduate theology knowledge but not that all your readers will have a PhD in the topic under consideration. Perhaps err on the side of simplicity and clarity rather than jargon. On the other hand, you are allowed to engage with detailed technical matters. If not everything in every book is for everyone, the same may be true of your review. 

 

If you quote, please give the page number. 

 

Make the review as long as it needs to be, taking into account the significance of the book and the importance of what you have to say. Sometimes you can’t say everything. Sometimes longer and shorter versions of a review might be useful. Could you publish a fuller version online with the permission of the journal? Brevity is probably the soul of wit. The journal may be open to a brief book note or to a longer review essay.

 

If this book is a re-write or second edition or re-publication or uses material previously published elsewhere etc. that may be information your public wants. You may wish to tell us if this book is part of a series or larger project. Is it volume 2 of 4?

 

If the journal has also reviewed some other work you mention please cite it e.g. in the form: TGA 2026 140/3, 282-3.

 

The academic review is not quite the same as a review in a magazine or newspaper, but you are still allowed to be engaging and interesting. How might you begin and end the review? Could your review be called predictable and formulaic? Can you give your review a hook or angle, rather than simply plodding through the chapters?

 

You may well feel moved to complain about the prices of academic books, but if we always did that our reviews would be rather samey.

 

Don’t moan about the book being American if it was written by an American for Americans, and you are writing for an American journal. If the journal has Global Anglican in the title, you might say how global Anglicans might find the book.

 

Check with the journal before publishing your review online.

 The Global Anglican, which used to be known as The Churchman, is available online or in print. 

We also have one page of A4 which sets out our “aspirations” for reviews etc., which you might find helpful.

 There is some information on the final page of The Global Anglican journal about how we understand our mission, our doctrinal commitments and about reviewing. We are always keen to hear from people who might like to review for us, and to receive suggestions of new or forthcoming books which you would like to see reviewed. We are normally able to arrange for publishers to provide reviewers with a free print or digital copy of the book for review. If and when we publish a review, we will send the reviewer a free print copy of the journal. The office also emails the reviews to the publishers. 

Church Society sometimes also publishes book reviews in its magazine Crossway or on its website and discusses books in its podcast.

* * *  

Thank you!

 

I would love to hear your thoughts.

(I give some suggestions on how to read more here. But remember, no skimming for book reviews, please!)

Monday, November 16, 2026

Diocesan Mission Action Plan Proposal

 

My new Mission Action Plan (a sign in the Rectory window offering free Bibles) is going so well, I thought I would propose something cheap and helpful to parish ministry which every diocese could do. The Church Commissioners could fund this as a 3-year experiment. The clergy could send an email to say if they found it helpful or not at the end of the trial period.

On Tuesdays in term time at 10:10am, the two most learned clergy in the diocese (say The Canon Chancellor and the Director of Ministerial Development) would have a Zoom call, which any clergy etc. could join. They would read out, and translate, and comment upon, and chat about how one might preach the Greek text of the Gospel for the coming Sunday until 10:40am. From 10:40am to 10:50am the clergy could ask questions. Clergy could also submit questions in advance to helpsortoutmysermon@dioceseofgodlyandlearnedclergy.anglican.co.uk.

No one would have to attend, but any clergy who logged on and concentrated would be entitled to a brief coffee break and a warm glow of self-righteousness.

Cheap, easy, helpful, focused on the core business of the church in every parish. What’s not to like? And even better the bureaucracy to implement and monitor this Excellent Leaders Programme would be minimal.  

Friday, November 13, 2026

A look at the end of Matthew's gospel with Christmas on the horizon

 

From The Rectory

 

I don’t promise to shut up about Matthew’s Gospel, but this parish magazine item is the final instalment of our year long look at this witness to Our Lord as part of the Diocesan Year of Matthew’s Gospel.

 

Earlier in the year we thought about the birth of Jesus and the visit of the Wise Men or Magi from the East. These ancient magician / philosopher / astronomer / astrologists are traditionally seen as representatives of the Nations, the Gentile non-Jews, coming to worship the Christ-child.

 

Matthew, and all the Gospels, concentrate on the adult Jesus – on his three years of public ministry, which it is generally thought he began around the age of 30. The narrative climaxes with the death and resurrection of Jesus in Jerusalem. But the final scene is back in Galilee of the Gentiles (28:16), where Jesus’ ministry began.

 

It seems in various ways Matthew’s ending deliberately echoes his beginning.

 

Chapter 1 reminds us of the Bible’s book of beginning, Genesis, when God made the heavens and the earth. “Heaven and earth” are also referred to in the last chapter (28:18). Jesus is bringing about a fresh start, a new beginning, a New Creation even.

 

Satanic temptation / testing is to be found at the beginning and the end of the Gospel (chapters 4, 6, 16, 19, 22 and 26 use this “tempt / test” word).

 

One small specific example is that Matthew is the only New Testament writer to quote the Prophet Jeremiah by name, in 2:18 and 27:9-10[1]. 

 

At the beginning and the end of the gospel there’s a threat from a King Herod (although they are not the same person). The birth of Jesus is followed by the death of the boys in Bethlehem. And, of course, Jesus himself dies. He was born to die.

 

After his birth, Jesus goes into a sort of exile to Egypt and then returns. Jesus’ cross (when he is cut off from the Father’s blessings because of sin, on our behalf) is an exile. The resurrection is a return.

 

There are angels at the birth and at the resurrection. Mary and Joseph were of course there at the beginning of Jesus’ story. At the cross and the tomb there are Marys. And Joseph of Arimathea arranges for Jesus’ burial.

 

The Wise Men worshiped Jesus (2:2, 8,11). At the end of the gospel, the disciples worship the risen Christ (28:9, 17). At the start of the gospel, representatives of the nations came to Christ. Now at the end of the gospel, Jesus sends his disciples as his representatives to disciple all the nations (28:19). The Wise Men sought the King of the Jews. Jesus is now shown to be the King the nations, of heaven and earth, the one who has been given all authority. Jesus is seeking a new worldwide family of worshipers. Before his birth, Jesus was revealed to be “Immanuel – God with us” (1:23) and now he promises to be with his disciples “always, to the very end of the age.”  

 

Why do I go on about all this? Well, partly just to enjoy the wonderful artistry of the Bible. But more importantly, clearly it was God’s plan that Jesus was born to die. The end was in the beginning. And Jesus’ end also offers us a new beginning – a death to sin and new eternal life with God.  

 

The Revd Canon Marc Lloyd



[1] I owe this and some of the other observations here to American Presbyterian The Revd Dr Peter Lienhart.

Saturday, October 31, 2026

Matthew 5vv1-12 handout

 For those who like this sort of thing:


Matthew 5vv1-12 (p968)

The Blessings of the Kingdom for Jesus’ Righteous People

 

v1 – Jesus teaching his disciples on a mountain (cf. Moses giving the Law)

 

“Blessed / Happy / Fortunate / Favoured”

 

The Beatitudes seem to fall in to two halves:

 

Part 1: vv3-6 – The first 4 Beatitudes (36 words) – all beginning with “p”!

v3 – present tense – “for theirs is the kingdom of heaven”

v6 – “righteousness”

 

Part 2: vv7-10 – The second 4 Beatitudes (36 words)

 v10 – “righteousness”

v10 – present tense – “for theirs is the kingdom of heaven”

 

Jesus’ people know their need

and live lives shaped by the Kingdom of God

 

(1) First half: Beatitudes 1-4:

Depending on grace, Jesus’ people long for his Kingdom (vv1-6)

 

(2) Second half: Beatitudes 5-8:

Transformed by grace, Jesus’ people live for his Kingdom (vv7-10)

 

The blessings of the Kingdom, now and not yet

 

Jesus The Blessed One

 

So…

 

when we fail… when we struggle… when life is good… 



Thursday, October 22, 2026

Parish Magazine Item for November 2026

 

From The Rectory – for November 2026

 

Over the last few weeks in church we’ve continued to think about the teaching of Jesus from Matthew’s Gospel. The set readings from the Church of England Lectionary put two parables in subsequent weeks: The Parable of the Unmerciful Servant (Matthew chapter 18 verses 21- 35) and The Parable of the Workers in the Vineyard (Matthew 20:1-16). You might like to take a moment to read them. As ever, you can find the sermons on the Warbleton Church website or You Tube channel.

 

As you’ll know, and as I’m often telling the children of Dallington Primary School, a parable is a (made up) story, with a meaning. Or as is sometimes said, ‘an earthly story, with a heavenly meaning’. The word ‘parable’ literally means to throw alongside. It suggests a parallel. Think of this in terms of that.

 

These two parables has some similarities. Jesus says that both of them are about what “the kingdom of heaven is like”. “Kingdom of heaven” probably means the same as “the Kingdom of God”. Devout Jews, like Matthew, would have been careful about using God’s name so as not to take it in vain (the third of the Ten Commandments – Exodus 20). Saying “heaven” as a way of meaning “God” could be safety precaution. In both parables there is someone in charge, a king or a landowner, who we can surmise stands for God the King. These stories tell us something about how God exercises his reign. And both are to do with money – which features very frequently in the teaching of Jesus – here in the form of debts and then in the form or wages.

 

We sometimes sing a song in church which neatly captures something of these two parables. The verses go like this:

 

Mercy is when God does not give us [the bad things, the judgement or penalties, we might say] which we deserve.   

 

And:

 

          Grace is when God gives us [the good things] we don’t deserve.

 

So what do these parables teach?

 

The Parable of the Unmerciful Servant. Mercy! We are all sinners. We all owe God a massive debt we can’t repay. Everything we have comes from him. We owe him our very lives. And morally speaking we are all deeply in the red. We fall short our own standards, let along God’s. None of our thoughts or actions is perfect, as they ought to be, so we should give up on any idea of repaying God or earning his love. That’s not the game! God is merciful. He forgives those who ask him. He is very kind and generous – amazingly so. And so we ought to be ready to forgive and show mercy to others.  

 

The Parable of the Workers in the Vineyard. Grace! God is generous. He gives us far more than we deserve. We ought to depend on his grace – his undeserved love – not demand our supposed rights. It is a mistake, in a way, to ask God for justice because (see the parable above) we all in fact deserve judgement. We may think we’re better than Jones or Smith. But what if our circumstances were different? Only God really knows the heart and can look at the whole. It’s not for us to judge one another. God gives his good gifts generously. And we ought to be thankful for that. We depend on that. It’s stupid to compare and be resentful. We are sinners who need grace.

 

Mercy and grace. They are wonderful complimentary truths. Trusting Jesus and his death for us, we can confidently look to God’s kindness. And we can pray that he would help us more and more to live out his grace and mercy to others.

The Revd Canon Marc Lloyd

Tuesday, October 13, 2026

More on The Four Senses

Following on from https://marclloyd.blogspot.com/2026/09/just-beginning-to-dip-into-patrick.html

 

Some further jottings from chapters one and two of Patrick Schreiner, The Four Sense of Scripture: Learning from Ancient Ways of Reading the Bible (Baker Academic, 2026):

 

Not a wooden or formulaic application of a method as if every text must be put through a procedure. “The four senses are more like parameters than a process, more of a mood than a method.” (p20) “a posture more than a program” (p22)

 

“Many texts can be read according to the four senses; sometimes a tree points back to the tree of life and forward to the cross. But sometimes a tree is just a tree…. the literal sense is always present, and sometimes the other senses are present too.” (p20)

 

“methods flow from metaphysics” (p20)

 

 The fourfold sense cohere with the nature of Scripture, of creation and history, and of language.

 

“Fourfold reading affirms that signs participate in the realities they point to. It entails a theology of history that understands everything as summed up in the mystery of Christ and progressing toward the future of Christ filling all things through his body, the church. Some modern forms of hermeneutics have been divorced from the ontology of the Scriptures and have uncritically swallowed the historical-critical pill. We have separated history from metaphysics, nature from grace, theology from Scripture, and Scripture from real life…. We must return to an enchanted, Christ-saturated way of viewing the world and the Scriptures.” (p21)

 

Four – completeness – more manageable than 7 or 12

 

Irenaeus on the 4 gospels (p21)

 

4 zones of the world, 4 winds, 4 horses, 4 cherubim – 4s in the Bible (p21 and footnote)

 

Augustine on The Good Samaritan – the inn keeper the Apostle (Paul) – see p25

 

The origin of the term “grammatical-historical exegesis” – first used by Karl Augustus Theophilos Keil in 1811  - and meaning – cf. historical critical method (p26) – Pontifical Biblical Commission definition

 

Origen and Aquinas also read the Good Samaritan in ways similar to Augustine (p27)

 

Vanhoozer: “Modern incomprehension of pre-modern reading cultures has less to do with reasoning than with contrasting interpretative intuitions” (p27, quoting Mere Xian Hermeneutics, p79)

 

John Cassian (d. 435) the first to name the four senses in Conference 14.8 NPNF2 11:438

 

“Most of the Reformers employed some form of them [the 4 senses] in their interpretations. However, they also responded to the excesses of the medieval period and tended to argue that all the senses should be brought under the literal sense.” (p30)

 

See p30 for Bible references to distinguishing literal and spirituals senses and allehorical, tropological and anagogical interpretation used in the Bible

 

The 4 sense are essentially 2 senses – literal and spiritual (p31)

 

Literal – littera – historical

Allegorical – allegoria – symbolic

Tropological – tropologia – moral

Anagogical – anagogia – futuristic (p31)

 

The allegorical has sometimes been known as typological, mystical, sacramental, spiritual, thewria (contemplation), hypnoia (deeper sense) (p31)

 

The quadria compared to a house (p33f)

 

Bonaventure – the spiritual senses compared to the theological virtues – The Soul’s Journey to God p91

Faith – allegory

Love – tropological

Hope – anagogical

 

The literal sense pointing back in time

The spiritual pointing forward

The tropological to our inward life

The anagogical to heaven (p35 - fn)

 

The senses and the offices of Christ:

King – speaking of what is true

Prophet – deeper meaning

Priest / Sage – how we are to act

Judge – what is to come (p35 - fn)

 

The four senses of Scripture and the human senses

Origen compared the senses to the senses of the body

Froehlich – literal sense & touch; allegory & seeing; tropology & hearing; anagogy & tasting

Allegory – the heart; tropology – the hands; anagogy – the head (p35 - fn)

 

Alexander of Hales, On Signification p41, sees the spiritual senses as rooted in the Trinity

Allegory pointing to Christ; Tropology – the Spirit’s work in the church; anagogy – the Father in the beatific vision (p35, fn)

 

“The revelation of Christ reveals the truth of the quadriga. Because God has acted in history by sending his Son, we have the literal sense. Because all history is united and glorified in Christ, we have the allegorical sense. Because Christ’s story is ours, we have tropology. Because Christ’s future is ours, we have anagogy.” (p37)

 

“The argument of this book is that fourfold interpretation is a faithful, helpful, historic, and holistic way of reading the Scriptures. This way of reading respects the historical context, views the Bible as a whole, connects to our lives, and points us to the future. It is a hermeneutical house we can live in.” (p40) – the grammatico historical method only provides a foundation (p44)

 

“God… is the primary author, subject matter, context, and aim of the Scriptures.” (p41)

 

Lectio divina and the four senses (p42f)

Reading (lectio) – the literal sense

Reflect (meditation) – the allegorical sense

Respond with speech in the form of prayer (oratio) – the tropological sense

Rest (contemplation) – the anagogical sense

 

“The four senses and lectio divina respect the ontology and telos of the Scriptures [that is, what it is and it’s goal]. Because Scripture is a divine-human product, we attend to both human and divine elements. And because the goal of reading is communion with God, we approach Scripture in a certain posture. The true way to read is to engage with love and wonder. We seek not only to know but also to be known, not only to hear, but also to be heard. It is the way of participation. Like Abraham with the mysterious visitors, we are to show hospitality to God as he graciously comes to us in the pages of the Bible.” (p44)   

Thursday, September 24, 2026

Have we made studying the Bible and preaching too hard?

 We are obviously all for the best possible Bible study and teaching. 

In my circles, there has sometimes been great stress on independent study of the text in the original languages. Then, and only then, consult the most technical commentary you can find, and a more devotional preaching type one. Aim to spend an hour for every minute of your sermon or Bible study. Remember to travel back to Corinth. Get the one single original intended meaning of the human author. Oh, have you got the right sense-unit? Obviously you need a theme sentence and an aim sentence and headings and an outline and an introduction and conclusion. You need to put it all in historical, literary, canonical and gospel context of course. How can you know what your text means unless you have mastered the book in which it appears? And you must plan your transition and timings. It will be 22.5 minutes long. The application might take a lot of work because how does the aim of the text for them relate to the aims of the text for each of us today in our different contexts, conditions and vocations. 

Now, much of that might be good and helpful. 

But:

Preach the good news of Jesus from this text for us and try not to be too long and boring. 

And pray. 

I reckon the people will thank you and Jesus will smile. 

Sometimes you are allowed to mention something not in the text. 

There may be more than one legitimate way to skin this cat. 

A bit of freedom and fun might help you. 

Of course opening the Bible is an awesome serious task. But let's not paralyse ourselves in fear of the divine sermon feedback! 

Reading with faith, hope and love

 Just beginning to dip into Patrick Schreiner, The Four Sense of Scripture: Learning from Ancient Ways of Reading the Bible (Baker Academic, 2026). 263pp

Schreiner is a Southern Baptist with a biblical studies PhD. He writes with learning and clarity. I am enjoying especially the pithy summaries. I am tempted, I think, to type out quite a lot of the book.

The appendixes are very helpful and include some material on how this could benefit the church and the preacher.

For other works recovering pre-critical exegesis, see footnotes on p3.

Henri de Lubac, a towering figuring in the ressourcement of pre-critical exegesis said "no one would dream of" a straightforward recovery of the four fold sense. But Schreiner says we should dare to dream! (p4), Actually, I think he is going to make some qualifications not endorse all pre-modern readings. He thinks four fold reading is basically natural and gravitational for the Christian. We know this text has a concrete meaning to its original hearers but that it must somehow speak to us of Christ for life and for eternity. This is the way the church deliberately read the Bible for 1700 years and it is essential to anyone who wants to preach a Christian sermon, not give a lecture.

I feel this should have been at the front of my mind, but nice to be reminded (?!) of the connection between the spiritual senses of Scripture and the theological virtues.

(1) Allegorical sense – Christological and ecclesial – faith;

(2) Tropological – moral – love

(3) Anagogical – eschatological - hope. Who could possibly be against reading the Bible with faith, love and hope?

(p230)

Schreiner summarises very nicely: The mystery of Christ is seen in allegory, filled up in tropology and consummated in anagogy. (p231)  

One of the nice things about this is how full of Jesus it is. Christ is the archetype and antitype. The substance and the goal. The Christian life is lived on the basis of his prior work, after his example, in him and with his body, for him and from him. We see him now in Scripture so that eventually we might see him face to face.

Some of the more technical language of the quadriga can be off putting and it is arguable how necessary and helpful it is. We could easily use terms more familiar to theological students in general e.g.

(Sense (1): Literal / grammatico-historical / contextual)

Sense (2): Christological

Sense (3): Ethical

Sense (4): Eschatological.

We could even try context (literary and historical etc.), Christ, Conformity (to Christ in living), Consummation (in Christ), or similar.

We might simply ask Bible readers to consider:

Sense (1): What does the text mean in its original setting?

Sense (2): How does it point to Christ and his church?

Sense (3): What does it mean for how we live as Christians?

Sense (4) How does it point to our glorious future in Christ?

(p233)

If we put it like that, then seeking these four senses in the Bible seems, perhaps, like an obvious no brainer. Though it is still a helpful reminder as we may be tempted to neglect or bypass or wrongly order these senses or steps. The questions alone, of course, do not answer the "how", where it would be possible to go wrong in many ways. We can have correct conclusions which we imposed on the text. But at least we are reminded to seek Jesus in this text. And that our reading should terminate in praise, Christ-like life and orientation to heaven and the new creation, not only to centuries past or to the present.

The Bible proceeds by a series of covenants. It's theme is the kingdom of God (p234)

We could say that the Bible commences, centres and culminates in Christ. Every text therefore has a Way to Christ. (cf. p234)

Schreiner argues that most of the church fathers spent most of their time on the literal sense, and so should we (p235)

It’s pretty obvious from a kind of literal reading that David is the Christ. He is the surprising Saviour-Shepherd who comes from his Father’s house to visit his brothers in need. He wins a victory by strange and unworldly means, defeating the evil death-bringing Giant, bringing peace, and becomes King.  

We should read the Bible Christoscopically. He is the scopos, the goal of it all. As Spurgeon said, he is the metropolis of the Bible to whom all roads lead. We can add things like Christological, Christocentric, Christotelic. Basically, we are for Christ, O!

When you think about it, isn't there something almost sacrilegious about a purely grammatico-historical reading of the Word of God? Like the beloved who returns the lover's letter covered in red ink. The Bible calls for trust, obedience, hope, adoration, not merely dissection and analysis.

8 reasons to recover the quadriga (p8ff)

With some qualifications, it is useful to distinguish the original intended meaning of the author and subsequent significations for future readers (pp10-11)

Grammatico-historical exegesis has much going for it, but good Bible reading also involves contemplation, participation and hospitality (p13)

7 clarifications (p14ff)

The term quadriga refers to four yoked together. The four senses must pull in a coherent direction. They are the benign four horsemen of hermeneutics. They have potential to help unify academy and church, and academic disciplines (biblical studies, biblical, historical, systematic, pastoral theology) (p14f)

We should affirm both the perspicuity and fecundity of the Bible. It is a world, a forest, an ocean, a feast, a treasure house. As Gregory the Great said, the Scriptures seem to grow with their reader. A lamb can find a footing in it and an elephant can float at large. It is not a puzzle to be solved by a method, but a mystery to be discerned by sensibilities (p18f)

Tuesday, September 22, 2026

School Harvest Sermonette

 I want to say:

(1) Stop and think about where your food comes from 

(2) Give thanks to / for those who help to feed you and to God who gives us all things

(3) Share 

Maybe that's THINK, THANK, THEM!

But others have suggested REFLECT, REJOICE, RESPOND 

and CONSIDER, CELEBRATE, CONTRIBUTE. 

Or, PAUSE, PRAISE and PASS IT ON.

It could be (1) Give thought (2) Give thanks (3) Give to others (or those in need). 


Monday, September 21, 2026

Free and unsolicited assignment advice

 

Free and unsolicited assignment advice

Which may also be relevant for sermon prep.

(1) As soon as you reasonably can, pick a question and brainstorm about it for 40 minutes. Write everything you know or can think of about it. What are all the angles and issues? What do you want to investigate? Where are the gaps in your knowledge or argument which you want to address?

This has at least two advantages:

(a) Get the issues in your head and you can ponder them as you shower or walk. They may on their own percolate into good things.

(b) You may also happen upon relevant stuff anywhere – in the paper, or library or internet

(2) Look into early how, where and when you will get the relevant books and resources. I’m told there can be a scramble for these and it is no good getting to a few days before the deadline and finding that everything is on loan to some keen bean or otherwise unavailable.

 

Are the kids snowflakes?

 

Are the kids snowflakes?

Yes, in some ways some of them probably are.

Yet some of their parents have been kidulting and maybe the sins of the parents are being visited on their children and grandchildren.

No doubt in many ways the lives of the little dears are pampered and protected with cotton wool. But they also face somewhat different challenges.

There have been no golden ages.

But 1950 was a bit simpler. You could leave school early and quickly get a decent job with honourable work and reasonable pay. Or you could go to university for free with no debt.

Arguably there was less freedom for self-expression. But perhaps it was a bit of a relief that there was a much more coherent and common vision of the good, the true and the beautiful. There was less pressure to invent, discover or curate some wonderful version of your individual genius. Not everyone always lived up to the standards or society, or even their own standards, of course, but there was more residual culture of Christendom in which one knew what a woman was, and so on. The project of life may have been more limited for many, but perhaps it was also less overwhelming and baffling.

 

 

“Happy Vicar; Happy Church” – Save the Vicar to Save the Parish

 

“Happy Vicar; Happy Church” – Save the Vicar to Save the Parish

 

There are several clarifications and qualifications we could make to this generalisation.

 

What do we mean here by “happy”, and is this our highest goal? Make it “joyful”, if you prefer.

 

Of course there are many other factors. This tag isn’t meant to pile more pressure on the Vicar because one of the problems is that she probably already feels too many competing, even contradictory demands and expectations. If the goal is pleasing all the people all the time, we know that’s a fool’s errand.

 

Churches can sometimes flourish despite their clergy who can be, as was once rather unfortunately said, “a bottle neck”. Imagine the perfectionist control freak Vicar: “my way or the highway”, perhaps.

 

But consider the opposite “sad, grumpy Vicar; dissatisfied, gloomy church”. No one wants a Vicar who is hurried, frazzled, tired, empty, bored, jittery, dreaming of nothing but a lottery win, retirement, or the alternative career he could have had for which it now seems too late.

 

That there is a problem is clear. Many clergy apparently show some signs of at least borderline mild depression. Retirements and resignations abound. Vocations are a challenge.

 

The causes of Vicar discontent can be complex. Compare his lot to that of the privileged 19th Century incumbent (not the unbeneficed perpetual curate!). He had a big house, plenty of money, servants, social respect, one church, no emails, WhatsApp, social media. Today there are several churches, no money, the church is at war with itself and treated like a supermarket by some (“I’d like to book a baptism slot on Wednesday 21st at 8pm, please”) and as irrelevant or malevolent by others. His kindly parishioners send his clippings from their newspaper of choice about how the church is woke or insufficiently woke. And the Diocese wants to reorganise him into a Missional Hub with people from the other ends of the candle stick. He may even like these people, but how they would minister together…. He could be forgiven for being rather distracted and confused, and pouring what energy he has into replacing the boiler or running the homeless shelter. So many good and worthy things can be done, but what about joyful Vicaring?

 

So what might the Vicar do if he is to seek happiness for the sake of Jesus and his church?

 

It may sound pious, but in the end, the Vicar has to seek Jesus the LORD. He has to find joy and satisfaction in him. His circumstances are not always going to be sufficient.

 

How might he do that? He should pray and read the Bible each day. And try to do so in a way that is unhurried and open. He needs some space to think each week and from time to time. He should really prepare his sermon such that he engages afresh with God and the text and his own soul. He must not rush too quickly to what he already knows or fall back on the first things which come to mind which he knows he could preach. He must seek encounter with Jesus. What he needs is the same Good News that everyone else needs. And he must feel that Jesus really is glad tidings of great joy that meet his predicament and that of all people. Then he will have something to preach with enthusiasm.  

 

And having been spiritual for a moment, he would do well to remember his humanity. E.g.

 

·       Go outside and have a walk

·       Take your days off and your annual leave

·       Cultivate friendships

·       Have some kind of hobby or hinterland

 

And how might the institution help him or her?

 

Many of the Save the Parish proposals seem sensible to me here. Maximum independence, maximum training and support. Prize theological training and depth. Encourage him to pray and work with others if that seems helpful, but don’t force him into some scheme or initiative. Value his vocation and him doing his job: prayer, Bible, sacraments, pastoral care, evangelism. Reasonable job security. No stupid tyrannical targets. Celebrate Vicars who Vicar.    

 

May God grant us happy clergy who can spread the joy!

Friday, September 18, 2026

Would state funded political parties sort it out?

Last night on BBC1’s Question Time (from Salisbury 17/9/26), Fiona asked the audience if they would be in favour of the state funding of political parties. A sea of hands.

 

But this seems to me a terrible idea.

 

I don’t want yet another tax to support proposals which I think would be disastrous.

 

And I’m not sure why we think the state would be any less corrupt, in its own way, than the status quo. The light of transparency is probably the best disinfectant. Let people and the people choose to whom they wish to give their money and their vote. If people really care about huge donations by individuals, it is open to them to give a little in their millions to support that politics which they want, as many people already support the Labour party via Trade Unions, though perhaps there’s more to say there.

 

Let’s not have the blob policing who can challenge the blob. There would of course be an enormous incentive for the established parties to disadvantage new entrants. The centre would always tend to favour itself and think it was doing the right thing, because they are the good right-thinking people, and the foolish ignorant public ought to know better. We should trust the political class to get on with it. What could possibly go wrong?

 

Perhaps your interactions with the state fill you with confidence about its efficiency?

 

I would love to see arguments made for a limited state and a free society.

 

“This is a problem, the state must solve it” is a mindset which infantilises us. Sometimes we have to live with the imperfect. And we should be sceptical that tax and spend will sort things out.

 

If the state stayed in its lane, perhaps we could manage sufficient defence spending, policing and criminal justice, which by common consent are currently a bit of a joke. We could consider being able to have ships at sea, and troops we could train and deploy. We may want a nuclear deterrent that is known to work. We could catch many of the bad guys, bring them to trial in a timely fashion, and make sure that they can serve their sentences.

 

A smaller state might allow for the flourishing of families and a big society. For schools and charities. For voluntary associations of all kinds which look to the common good of their places and people. The wisdom of the village might prove greater than that of the lanyarded committee from Whitehall.  

Tuesday, September 15, 2026

Christian Podcasts / audio / video etc.

 

What free Christian audio / video / podcasts would you recommend?

(This list started with some suggestions suitable for new Christians, but I've expanded it). 

I’ve even included some which, as far as I know, has nothing to do with the Scrivener family!

 

I’m not a big user of this stuff myself (though I do like David Suchet to read the NIV UK to me via Bible Gateway) but I’ve been asking around.

 

Maybe some of the Word One To One stuff – esp Come and See Podcast - https://www.theword121.com/

 

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCVI3tnVMJR8j3IWqvsPftOA

 

The Revd Dr Matt Searles is a good chap - https://www.mattsearles.uk/bible-overbrew

 

Two Sisters & a cup of tea podcast - https://www.twosistersandacupoftea.com/

 

Emma Scrivener, Jack Timpany & Graeme Johnstone - https://open.spotify.com/show/4XIprCIo4KPoFaQ1UwdDZw

 

I sometimes watch some of Glen Scrivener (Speak Life) - https://speaklife.org.uk/

https://www.youtube.com/@SpeakLifeMedia

 

The Rector of Burwash would tell me to mention: Irreverend Faith and Current Affairs

-          https://irreverendpod.com/

A friend has also reminded me of The Church Society Podcast, what I have even been on, twice! https://www.churchsociety.org/resources/podcast/

Union Theological College, Belfast:

https://www.union.ac.uk/utc-podcast

Oak Hill College, London, where I went twice! https://www.oakhill.ac.uk/about/resources?type=podcast


Friday, September 11, 2026

The parable of the unmerciful servant (Matthew 18) - some headings

 I don't always use sermon headings, and I might actually just walk though the story on Sunday. But I have been playing around with different headings and how this might be preached. I'd love to hear what you have or have heard, improvements, suggestions and comments always welcome. 


Do you know your net worth?

 

(1) You owe a huge debt to God which you cannot possibly repay

 

(2) God graciously forgives you your huge debt if you asked him for mercy

 

(3) Are you ready, in response to God’s grace, to forgive the lesser debts which others owe you?

 

(4) If you are not prepared to show mercy to others, you can’t expect mercy from God

 

* * *

 

(1) We owe God huge debt

 

(2) God offers us a huge mercy

 

(3) We are capable of huge inconsistency

 

(4) We need a huge mercy-judgement rethink

 

(a) A huge re-think of God, his mercy and judgement. We must seek mercy but we mustn’t expect mercy if we will not offer mercy.

 

(b) A huge re-think of ourselves and our relationships. We must seek and offer mercy, not stand on our supposed rights.

 

* * *

One useful way to read the Bible can be to give particular attention to things that we find surprising or strange.

Maybe in this passage we can pick out some surprises

(1) We are to endlessly offer forgiveness, not reasonably or even generously, keep score

(2) We owe a huge debt we can’t repay, not “well, of course, nobody’s perfect and I include myself in that”

(3) God is completely and extravagantly merciful, not “yes, you can perhaps work off your debt eventually”

(4) God will judge those who have not really accepted mercy, not automatic universal forgiveness