Monday, September 21, 2026

“Happy Vicar; Happy Church” – Save the Vicar to Save the Parish

 

“Happy Vicar; Happy Church” – Save the Vicar to Save the Parish

 

There are several clarifications and qualifications we could make to this generalisation.

 

What do we mean here by “happy”, and is this our highest goal? Make it “joyful”, if you prefer.

 

Of course there are many other factors. This tag isn’t meant to pile more pressure on the Vicar because one of the problems is that she probably already feels too many competing, even contradictory demands and expectations. If the goal is pleasing all the people all the time, we know that’s a fool’s errand.

 

Churches can sometimes flourish despite their clergy who can be, as was once rather unfortunately said, “a bottle neck”. Imagine the perfectionist control freak Vicar: “my way or the highway”, perhaps.

 

But consider the opposite “sad, grumpy Vicar; dissatisfied, gloomy church”. No one wants a Vicar who is hurried, frazzled, tired, empty, bored, jittery, dreaming of nothing but a lottery win, retirement, or the alternative career he could have had for which it now seems too late.

 

That there is a problem is clear. Many clergy apparently show some signs of at least borderline mild depression. Retirements and resignations abound. Vocations are a challenge.

 

The causes of Vicar discontent can be complex. Compare his lot to that of the privileged 19th Century incumbent (not the unbeneficed perpetual curate!). He had a big house, plenty of money, servants, social respect, one church, no emails, WhatsApp, social media. Today there are several churches, no money, the church is at war with itself and treated like a supermarket by some (“I’d like to book a baptism slot on Wednesday 21st at 8pm, please”) and as irrelevant or malevolent by others. His kindly parishioners send his clippings from their newspaper of choice about how the church is woke or insufficiently woke. And the Diocese wants to reorganise him into a Missional Hub with people from the other ends of the candle stick. He may even like these people, but how they would minister together…. He could be forgiven for being rather distracted and confused, and pouring what energy he has into replacing the boiler or running the homeless shelter. So many good and worthy things can be done, but what about joyful Vicaring?

 

So what might the Vicar do if he is to seek happiness for the sake of Jesus and his church?

 

It may sound pious, but in the end, the Vicar has to seek Jesus the LORD. He has to find joy and satisfaction in him. His circumstances are not always going to be sufficient.

 

How might he do that? He should pray and read the Bible each day. And try to do so in a way that is unhurried and open. He needs some space to think each week and from time to time. He should really prepare his sermon such that he engages afresh with God and the text and his own soul. He must not rush too quickly to what he already knows or fall back on the first things which come to mind which he knows he could preach. He must seek encounter with Jesus. What he needs is the same Good News that everyone else needs. And he must feel that Jesus really is glad tidings of great joy that meet his predicament and that of all people. Then he will have something to preach with enthusiasm.  

 

And having been spiritual for a moment, he would do well to remember his humanity. E.g.

 

·       Go outside and have a walk

·       Take your days off and your annual leave

·       Cultivate friendships

·       Have some kind of hobby or hinterland

 

And how might the institution help him or her?

 

Many of the Save the Parish proposals seem sensible to me here. Maximum independence, maximum training and support. Prize theological training and depth. Encourage him to pray and work with others if that seems helpful, but don’t force him into some scheme or initiative. Value his vocation and him doing his job: prayer, Bible, sacraments, pastoral care, evangelism. Reasonable job security. No stupid tyrannical targets. Celebrate Vicars who Vicar.    

 

May God grant us happy clergy who can spread the joy!

No comments: